In Montana, a case study in rape culture
Montana judge denied do-over
STORY HIGHLIGHTS
- Lyn Mikel Brown: Montana teen raped, teacher confessed, then judge gave 30-day sentence
- Judge said girl looked older, was in control, teacher had "suffered"
- Brown: Culture's distorted message about girls gives men like rapist -- and judge -- a pass
- Brown: Girls struggle to navigate this terrain; judges must be wise enough to understand it
Editor's note: Lyn
Mikel Brown, Ed.D., is a professor of education at Colby College. She is
the author of "Packaging Girlhood" and co-founder of SPARK Movement, an
intergenerational activist campaign challenging the sexualization of
girls, andHardy Girls Healthy Women, a nonprofit organization based in
Waterville, Me. and dedicated to the health and well being of girls and
women.
(CNN) -- Recently in my hometown, a 44-year-old male
teacher was arrested for unlawful touching of a minor and possessing
child pornography.
A 12-year-old told and
someone believed her. Thousands of pornographic pictures of children
were found on his laptop, according to the County District Attorney.
(The accused "denies any wrongdoing of any kind," his lawyer said, and
lawyers on both sides said the charges did not involve students.)
Whatever the outcome of
this case, I fear for this child. Someone believed 14-year-old Cherice
Moralez of Billings Montana, too, when she accused her 49-year-old teacher, Sandy Rambold, of forcible rape. He confessed, faced charges and then should have received a sentence commensurate with the crime of rape.
But the legal process
played out over three years, and just before her 17th birthday, Moralez,
shamed and shunned by classmates, shot herself. District Judge G. Todd
Baugh sentenced Rambold to just 30 days. (The public outrage that
followed caused Baugh to attempt a review of his own sentencing, a move
the Montana State Supreme Court denied last week.)
"He'd suffered enough,"
Baugh said of Rambold at the initial sentencing, and besides, Moralez,
"older than her chronological age," was "as much in control of the
situation" as her teacher, he said. "Obviously a 14-year-old can't
consent," the judge explained in the wake of public outrage, but this
wasn't "some violent, forcible, horrible rape." It wasn't, said the
judge, "this forcible beat-up rape."
Where does this bizarre
line of reasoning come from? We need only look around for clues at a
media culture that regularly tells young girls that growing up means
shedding all signs of pink princess innocence for a porn version of
sexy. A culture that celebrates Robin Thicke singing, "I know you want
it" at the VMAs as Miley Cyrus -- having made the lightening quick
transformation from teen role model to sex object,whose job it is to
give pleasure to a grown man-- twerks in his crotch.
We reward girls and young
women who take off their clothes, tell them that their sexual
availability and sexual power are their most important assets. We grant
them record deals, reality TV shows, and global news coverage. Once they
cross over, slut-shaming and Judge Baugh-like sentences enable men like
Rambold to take full advantage -- as long as it's not "this forcible
beat-up rape."
We rarely hear from young
women themselves about what it's like to traverse this cultural
terrain. So I asked members of the SPARKteam (girl activists ages 13-22
from SPARK Movement) to talk about what happened to Cherice. What does
it feel like to be 14 and want to be wanted, to experience this new kind
of power and illusion of control?
Erin, 18, says she
immediately identified with Cherice, because "I was her. I remember
being 14 and talking to 30 year-olds on the Internet. I was feeling
really alone and struggling to come to terms with who I was. I wanted to
have some kind of social (and sexual) connection with people. That's
what led me to leer in chat rooms and talk to men who were more than
twice my age. Maybe they would love me and maybe I could feel less
insecure."
Erin knows firsthand how
easy it is "to get caught up in your undying feelings for someone,
especially someone who is manipulating you into loving them. At 14, you
think that you know everything -- you think this person isn't doing
anything wrong by having a relationship with you, and that no one
understands. He becomes your world. You think that you're in love, when
what you're really in is abuse."
"When you're 14,"
15-year-old Luci says. "It seems like the rest of the world is against
you, especially if, as the judge described Morales, you're 'a troubled
kid.' I can get that, and I can see why Cherice found refuge in a
relationship with her teacher. When I was her age, there was this one
teacher who everyone at my school adored. He saw potential in me that I
was too insecure to see in myself. I looked like I could be in college.
He treated me like I was grown up, so I thought I was more mature than I
really was. But that's the thing: Looking older than you are in no way
equals being emotionally mature."
Celeste, 20, implicates
Judge Baugh's unquestioned participation "in a culture where
representations of Latinas prioritize sex appeal. Baugh's claims speak
volumes about the way women of color are hypersexualized. Cherice was
only 14, but when Baugh looked at her he saw someone older who was
therefore experienced enough to understand, and even control, a sexual
situation. She did not fit his image of 'youth' and 'purity,' so this
70-year-old Judge did not see a young girl who was victimized, but a
sexually viable woman."
Because the lines are
blurred, we need judges who are educated and aware enough to see through
the subterfuge of sexism and racism, who do the right thing -- whether
in Steubenville, Billings, or my hometown. Whatever else is going on in
girls' lives, whatever media messages we all receive about the
commodification of their sexuality, we need to send a clear message that
rape and sexual assault are crimes for a reason, that justice has
nothing to do with how mature a girl looks or acts and everything to do
with her suffering and her right to human dignity.
No comments:
Post a Comment